Direct Tax Code (DTC) vs. Income Tax Act (ITA): A Comprehensive Comparison

Understanding the Direct Tax Code (DTC)

What is the Direct Tax Code?

The Direct Tax Code (DTC) is a proposed legislation designed to replace the current Income Tax Act (ITA) of 1961. It was introduced to simplify direct tax laws in India and bring them in line with evolving economic practices.

But does it impact the income tax basics? And how exactly does it differ from the current framework? 

This comparison of the Direct Tax Code vs Income Tax Act will help you understand the changes and how they affect the fundamentals of income tax basics. 

Objectives and Goals of the DTC

The DTC aims to simplify a tax system that has become complex due to overlapping exemptions and inconsistent interpretations under the Income Tax Act. It focuses on easier compliance, broader taxpayer participation, fewer disputes, and greater transparency. With simplified rules and fewer exemptions, it also aims to improve voluntary compliance, reduce the tax burden through wider tax bases, and increase consistency across tax provisions.

Key Features of the DTC

1. Simplification of Tax Laws

The DTC simplifies tax language and reduces the need for cross-referencing between sections. This is helpful for both individuals and businesses to understand what is income tax and how it applies to them.

2. Reduction in Litigation

Many tax disputes today arise due to unclear language or conflicting interpretations. The DTC aims to cut down these legal challenges by making tax rules easier to interpret. Clear guidelines are especially helpful for professionals such as a stock investment advisor, who often work with clients to align financial planning with changing tax rules.

3. Enhanced Transparency

With clearer definitions and simplified rules, the DTC improves transparency and reduces confusion. It makes it easier for individuals and businesses to understand and follow tax laws, encouraging voluntary compliance over the older, more complex Income Tax Act.

4. Provisions for Digital Economy Taxation

The DTC includes proposals that account for the fast-growing digital economy. With more businesses and individuals earning through online platforms, the code adds clarity on how digital income should be taxed, making it more relevant in today’s tech-driven world.

Understanding the Income Tax Act (ITA) of 1961

Overview of the ITA 1961

If you’re starting with income tax concepts, the ITA is the current go-to structure. Introduced in the twelfth year of India’s Republic, the Income Tax Act, 1961, governs the taxation of income for individuals and businesses. It outlines rules for exemptions, deductions, compliance, and penalties. 

The Act applies to income earned in the previous year and is administered by the Central Government. Over time, the Act has grown to 23 chapters, 298 sections, and over 1,000 sub-sections, reflecting its complex evolution in response to India’s changing economic landscape.

Major Provisions and Sections of the ITA

The ITA (both old and new regimes) contains detailed provisions to ensure fair, transparent, and efficient taxation. Some of the significant provisions include:

1. Right to Appeal:

• Section 260A: Appeal to the High Court
• Section 261: Appeal to the Supreme Court

2. Assessment and Taxation Process:

• Self-assessment, summary, and scrutiny assessments
• Power and responsibility of assessing officers
• TDS mandates for timely tax collection

3. Allowable Deductions & Slabs:

• Sections 80C, 80D, and 80G for deductions
• Tax calculation based on income slabs

4. Compliance and Enforcement:

• Penalties for non-compliance or evasion
• Prosecution in extreme cases
• Defined process for financial transaction statements

5. Administration and Transparency:

• Clear guidelines for transaction reporting
• Representation through authorised personnel
• Instructions to subordinate tax authorities

Shortcomings and Challenges of the ITA

Despite its depth, the ITA faces several challenges in the modern context:

1. Complex Structure: The Act has grown to a vast and intricate legal framework, with multiple sections and sub-clauses, making compliance and interpretation difficult for taxpayers.
2. Personal Tax Slabs: The current slab system is seen as cluttered, and multiple tax brackets create confusion.
3. Savings Taxation: Debate continues between EET (Exempt-Exempt-Taxed) and EEE (Exempt-Exempt-Exempt) systems, as they lack consistency
4. Corporate Tax Gaps: Though the 2024 budget addressed capital gains and reduced corporate tax rates, areas like group tax consolidation still need reform for a more unified tax experience across corporate entities.

Key Differences Between DTC and ITA

Parameter	Income Tax Act (ITA), 1961	Direct Taxes Code (DTC)
Tax Slabs and Rates	Multiple slabs with frequent revisions; complex exemptions and deductions	Proposes fewer, broader slabs; simplified rate structure with higher exemption thresholds
Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) and Tax Collected at Source (TCS)	Detailed TDS/TCS provisions across sections and income types	Aims to consolidate and simplify TDS/TCS mechanisms for easier compliance
Dispute Resolution Mechanisms	Traditional appellate structure involving ITAT, HC, SC	Proposes faster resolution with alternative mechanisms like Dispute Resolution Panels (DRPs)
Applicability to the Digital Economy	Limited coverage; relies on newer amendments like Equalisation Levy	Intends to address digital transactions more holistically with updated definitions and rules
Compliance and Reporting Requirements	Complex filing norms; several forms, statements, and assessments	Targets simplified reporting, fewer forms, and reduced compliance burden

The Proposed Transition from ITA to DTC

Timeline for Implementation

There is no official implementation date for the DTC yet. It remains under review and discussion by policymakers.

Expected Impact on Taxpayers

For individual taxpayers and businesses, the DTC promises less paperwork, more predictability, and improved clarity on tax obligations. The possible changes for this are expected to include the following:

• Residential status will be simplified to just “Resident” and “Non-Resident.”
• Tax filing will align with the “Financial Year,” removing older year-based terms.
• Revised slabs and reduced exemptions aim to simplify calculations and reduce misuse.
• Capital gains (except listed securities) will be taxed like regular income.
• Uniform corporate tax rates and expanded audit eligibility (CS, CMA) will ease compliance.
• Wider TDS/TCS coverage will ensure steadier, source-based tax collection.

Challenges in the Transition Process

While the intent behind DTC is progressive, its transition presents several hurdles:

• Structural Overhaul: Transitioning from a 298-section Act to a simplified code will require massive updates to tax systems, software, and processes.
• Training and Awareness: Tax officials, professionals, and taxpayers will need retraining to understand the new provisions, definitions, and compliance timelines.
• Resistance to Change: Businesses and political stakeholders have raised concerns about the removal of exemptions and changes to capital gains, which could impact investor sentiment and business profitability.
• Technology and Infrastructure Gaps: Upgrading digital tax filing infrastructure and linking financial systems to comply with the new rules may be a major logistical challenge.
• Impact on Investments: Changes in capital gains treatment and mutual fund taxation could alter investment decisions and potentially affect foreign direct investment (FDI).

.

Conclusion

Summary of Key Differences and Implications

While the ITA is detailed and well-established, it often feels complicated. The DTC, with its emphasis on simplification and transparency, aims to make taxation more manageable. Understanding the Direct Tax Code vs Income Tax Act will thus help you prepare for possible changes in tax filing and compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. When will the DTC be implemented?

There is no fixed timeline yet. The proposal is still under government review.

2. How will the DTC affect different taxpayer categories (Individuals, Businesses, etc.)?

The DTC plans to make tax rules more consistent across taxpayer categories, which can help both salaried individuals and businesses manage taxes better.

3. What are the benefits of the DTC?

Simpler compliance, better clarity, and updated rules for digital income sources.

4. What are the potential drawbacks of the DTC?

Transitioning could take time and may need significant adjustments for businesses and tax advisors.

5. What support will be provided to taxpayers during the transition?

Government-led guidance, digital tools, and support from investment and tax advisors are expected during the rollout.

Disclaimer Note: The securities quoted, if any, are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. This article is for education purposes only and shall not be considered as a recommendation or investment advice by Equentis – Research & Ranking. We will not be liable for any losses that may occur. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. Registration granted by SEBI, membership of BASL & certification from NISM in no way guarantee the performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.