LIC vs SIP: Which is Better for Building Wealth?

Introduction

Why People Compare LIC and SIP for Financial Planning

When it comes to financial planning, the first few non-negotiables people typically add to their portfolio include insurance and investment products, along with other essential items. The options many opt for to start building their ideal portfolio are LIC and SIP plans. Both are popular choices in India but serve different purposes. That’s why comparing LIC vs SIP often arises when deciding where to invest your money and how much to allocate to both, in the case of combined investments. 

The Importance of Understanding What You’re Investing In

Before making any financial decision, it’s essential to understand the purpose of each option. When comparing a LIC policy vs SIP, you’re not just choosing between two products—you’re deciding how you want to secure your future and grow your money.

If your goal is family protection while you are the sole breadwinner, a LIC term policy will be ideal for life insurance to keep your loved ones financially secure.  Say you’re saving for your child’s education 10–15 years away, a SIP, checked with a SIP calculator, can steadily grow your wealth. And if you want both safety and growth, you can split your investment between a Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) and a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP).

Hence, when you clearly understand different concepts like SIPs, what are SIFs, and what LIC policies offer, it becomes easier to choose the right mix that suits your goals, not just now, but years down the line.

What is a LIC (Life Insurance Corporation) Policy?

Definition and Purpose of LIC Policies

A LIC policy is a contract where you pay regular premiums to the Life Insurance Corporation of India in exchange for a promise of financial support. In case of your untimely death, your family receives a lump sum payout. In some plans, if you outlive the policy term, you receive a maturity benefit. LIC offers a variety of life insurance plans, which fall into two main categories:

• Pure Protection Plans: These plans focus solely on providing life insurance coverage. Term insurance is a good example.
• Protection and Savings Plans: These combine insurance with a savings or investment component to help you meet long-term goals

Types of LIC Policies

There are different types of LIC policies, such as:

1. Term Insurance Plans: These offer life cover for a fixed period. If something happens during this term, your family gets the sum assured. Premiums are lower compared to other policies.
2. Endowment Plans: These combine savings and insurance. You get a lump sum either on maturity or in case of an untimely event.
3. ULIPs (Unit Linked Insurance Plans): A mix of life cover and investment. Part of your premium is allocated towards market-linked funds, offering a higher return option.
4. Money Back Plans: These return a part of the sum assured at regular intervals during the policy term. The remainder is paid on maturity or to your nominees upon death.
5. Whole Life Plans: These cover you for your entire lifetime. A lump sum is paid to your beneficiaries after your death, no matter when that occurs.
6. Pension Plans: These are retirement-focused plans that also offer life cover. At maturity, you receive a regular income or a lump sum payout.

LIC as a Traditional Investment Avenue

For decades, LIC policies have been a go-to option for Indian households seeking stability and long-term protection. The stable returns, life insurance coverage, and tax benefits are attractive, especially for those seeking a low-risk option. That’s why when you think about LIC policy vs SIP, you’re essentially comparing a safety-first approach to a growth-oriented one.

What is SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)?

How SIP Works as a Mode of Mutual Fund Investment

SIP, or Systematic Investment Plan, is a method of investing in mutual funds. Here, you invest a fixed amount regularly, monthly or quarterly, into a mutual fund scheme of your choice. This helps build financial discipline, leading to a steady level of wealth over time.

SIP for Long-Term Wealth Creation

The biggest advantage of SIP is compounding, where your returns start earning returns, helping your money grow faster over time. It is a disciplined way to build wealth through regular, market-linked investments. You can also use a SIP calculator to estimate how much your investments could grow based on the amount and duration.

LIC vs SIP: Key Differences Explained

1. Investment Objective: Protection vs Wealth Accumulation

LIC policies focus on life protection with some savings. SIPs, on the other hand, are designed to grow your wealth over the long term. So, when comparing LIC vs SIP, you need to ask yourself what your primary goal is: security or growth?

2. Return Potential and Risk

LIC returns are low to moderate, but they’re steady. SIPs, especially those in equity funds, have higher return potential but come with market risk. You can consult a stock advisory company to better understand where to invest if you’re going the SIP route.

3. Lock-in Period and Liquidity

LIC policies come with long lock-in periods, making early withdrawals difficult. SIPs are more flexible; you can stop or redeem them as needed (unless it’s an ELSS with a 3-year lock-in).

4. Tax Benefits under Section 80C

Both LIC and SIPs (if investing in ELSS) offer tax deductions under Section 80C. However, the deduction is available only in the old tax regime.

5. Transparency, Flexibility, and Ease of Investing

SIPs are more transparent. You can track mutual fund performance easily, adjust your contribution, or switch funds. LIC policies may lack this kind of flexibility.

LIC Policy vs SIP: Which is Better and When?

Use Cases Where LIC May Be Preferred

LIC policies primarily focus on life insurance, offering financial protection to dependents in case of an unfortunate event. Hence, LIC can be a choice in the following cases:

• For investors seeking guaranteed stable returns with life cover. 
• Preferred by individuals with low risk appetite. 
• Long-term commitments that may align with individuals seeking fixed maturity benefits over time.
  

Situations Where SIP Offers Greater Advantages

SIPs are designed for regular investments in mutual funds, aiming at long-term capital appreciation to achieve long-term financial goals, such as retirement or children’s education. Hence, SIP can be your choice: 

• When your focus is on long-term wealth building.
• When you want flexible investment options with higher returns.
  

Should You Combine Both for Balanced Planning?

Combining LIC and SIP can be a practical approach if you want both financial protection and long-term growth. If you’re just starting out or unsure about where to begin, using both can help strike a balance; LIC for security, SIP for growth. This way, you don’t rely on one product to do everything and can plan better based on your risk appetite and financial goals.

LIC vs SIP: Real-World Return Comparison

Example 1: Traditional LIC Endowment Plan vs SIP in Equity Fund

Let’s assume you invest ₹5,000 per month in either a LIC endowment plan (with 9.5% returns- assumed basis the rate stated by LIC for single-premium endowment plan for May 2024 to April 2025) or an equity mutual fund via SIP (with 12% returns- assumed considering average SIP return is between 12% and 18%) for 20 years. Here’s how the investment growth looks in both scenarios:

Parameter	LIC Endowment Plan (9.5%)	SIP in Equity Fund (12%)
Monthly Investment	₹5,000	₹5,000
Investment Tenure	20 years	20 years
Total Investment	₹12,00,000	₹12,00,000
Maturity Amount (approx.)	₹32.8 lakhs	₹50.9 lakhs
Risk Level	Low	Moderate to High
Liquidity	Low	High
Purpose	Insurance + Savings	Long-Term Wealth Creation

Example 2: Monthly Contribution in Both Over 15 Years

Assume you invest ₹10,000/month in a LIC endowment plan (9.5% returns) and ₹10,000/month in an equity mutual fund SIP (12% returns) for 15 years. Here’s how the investments grow:

Parameter	LIC Endowment Plan (₹10,000 @ 9.5%)	SIP in Equity Fund (₹10,000 @ 12%)	Combined Total
Monthly Investment	₹10,000	₹10,000	₹20,000
Investment Tenure	15 years	15 years	15 years
Total Investment	₹18,00,000	₹18,00,000	₹36,00,000
Maturity Amount (approx.)	₹37.9 lakhs	₹52.7 lakhs	₹90.6 lakhs
Outcome	Safety + Modest Returns	Market-Linked Growth	Balanced Growth + Safety

Splitting your monthly investment equally between LIC and SIP combines the security of life cover and stable returns with the growth potential of equity markets, resulting in a balanced portfolio.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: LIC Gives Guaranteed High Returns

LIC policies focus on providing financial protection through life cover. While they do offer returns, these are generally moderate and not designed for high wealth growth. The main purpose is safety and security for your family.

Myth: SIP is Only for Market Experts

Investing in SIPs does not require deep market knowledge. You can start with small amounts, invest regularly, and use tools like a SIP calculator to understand potential growth. Consistency and long-term planning matter more than expertise.

Myth: You Can’t Do Both

It’s not about choosing between LIC or SIP. Many people use LIC policies for life insurance and SIPs for growing their investments. Combining both helps cover protection needs while building wealth over time.

Conclusion

LIC vs SIP is Not Just About Returns

Both LIC and SIPs serve different purposes. While LIC is about safety and protection, an SIP is about growth and flexibility.

Choosing the Right Option Depends on Your Financial Goals

If you’re looking for life cover, LIC works well. If you want to grow wealth over time, a SIP is a better option. And if you want both, a balanced approach makes sense. It’s not about choosing one over the other; it’s about understanding how each fits into your financial plan.

Disclaimer Note: The securities quoted, if any, are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. This article is for education purposes only and shall not be considered as a recommendation or investment advice by Equentis – Research & Ranking. We will not be liable for any losses that may occur. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. Registration granted by SEBI, membership of BASL & certification from NISM in no way guarantee the performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.