From Stores to Your Doors: Will the New Reform Revolutionize India’s Alcohol Market?

Imagine ordering your favorite beer or wine for a cozy night in, delivered straight to your doorstep. This seemingly simple act could be a game-changer for India’s alcohol industry, with ramifications for consumers, businesses, and state governments.

But before we uncork the champagne of celebration, let’s delve into the planned reforms, their potential benefits and challenges, and how they position India in the global alcoholic beverage landscape.

A Long-Awaited Transformation

For years, whispers of reform have swirled around India’s alcohol industry, particularly regarding home delivery of alcoholic beverages. While a global trend, India has lagged behind, with only fleeting experiments during the COVID-19 lockdowns. A wave of optimism is rising, with several states – Delhi, Karnataka, Haryana, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Goa, and Kerala – testing pilot projects for home delivery of low-alcohol content beverages.  

A Story of Starts and Stops

While home delivery of alcohol is a growing trend globally, India’s journey has been more stop-start.  The initial steps came during the COVID-19 lockdowns when physical stores were shut.  While some states like Jharkhand and Maharashtra allowed temporary home deliveries to curb outlet overcrowding, the momentum fizzled out. 

Despite consumer demand, several hurdles persist.  States have often experimented with, then abandoned, home delivery models.  Odisha and West Bengal are the exceptions, with Swiggy and Spencer’s delivering in over 20 West Bengal cities and Swiggy operating in select Odisha cities.  These deliveries have reportedly led to a 20-30% increase in premium spirit sales, demonstrating the potential demand. 

Benefits and Revenue Streams

The potential windfall from home delivery of alcoholic beverages extends far beyond a simple convenience for consumers. Let’s dissect the potential benefits for each stakeholder group:

• E-commerce Platforms: Imagine you’re relaxing at home, craving a specific beer or a bottle of wine to complement your dinner. With home delivery, a few clicks on your phone could see your desired beverage arrive at your doorstep within a designated timeframe. This convenience significantly boosts gross order values (GOV) for e-commerce platforms like Zomato, Blinkit, Swiggy, BigBasket, and Zepto. 

Experts estimate a potential increase of 5-8% in GOV, which translates to a substantial rise in their overall business volume. This growth can fuel platform expansions, improve their service offerings, and potentially lead to lower delivery fees for consumers in the long run.

• Consumers: Convenience isn’t the only perk for consumers. Home delivery offers a wider selection of alcoholic beverages compared to the limited options often available at local liquor stores. This expanded choice allows for a more personalized experience, catering to individual preferences. 

Additionally, concerns about safety, especially for women and senior citizens who might feel intimidated by traditional liquor stores, could be significantly reduced. Home delivery fosters a safe and comfortable environment for consumers to make their purchases.

State-Wise Impact: A Tailored Approach

The impact of home delivery on state governments will vary depending on their existing excise policies and revenue structures. States with a high dependence on alcohol sales for revenue, like Tamil Nadu, could see a significant boost in VAT and excise collections if home delivery leads to increased sales volume. However, the financial impact might be less pronounced for states with a more diversified revenue base.

While the potential benefits are undeniable, each state must carefully consider the specific needs of its population and craft regulations that promote responsible consumption and prevent any potential misuse of the system. This might involve setting limitations on order quantities, delivery timings, and the types of beverages allowed for home delivery.

• State Governments: For state governments in India, alcohol sales are a goldmine, generating a substantial portion of their revenue through excise duties and Value Added Tax (VAT). Look at the figures: Tamil Nadu alone raked in a staggering INR 45,855 crore from liquor sales in 2023-24, with a significant chunk coming from VAT and excise. Delhi, another major market, witnessed excise revenue of INR 7,484 crore during the same period.

The Roadblocks: Challenges and Concerns

Despite the alluring prospects, challenges remain. Previous attempts at home delivery fizzled out due to a variety of factors.  Steep delivery fees charged by aggregators, unclear guidelines from state governments, and brick-and-mortar retailers’ resistance played a role.

Additionally, some are worried about the misrepresentation of policies and the potential for unchecked online sales. These concerns, coupled with political resistance, hampered earlier efforts.  However, the biggest hurdle has been political backlash and public misconceptions surrounding online alcohol sales.

Evolving Consumer Base and Modernization

However, the landscape is shifting.  The growing expat population and lowering legal drinking age in India are contributing to a changing consumer base.  This new generation views moderate alcohol consumption as a social activity often enjoyed with meals.  Furthermore, most liquor stores outside major cities are small, unappealing spaces that may deter women and senior citizens.  

Industry leaders believe these apprehensions are unfounded. Legitimate online platforms implement stringent checks, such as mandatory eKYC and age verification, delivery personnel tracking, purchase limits, and OTP verifications, to ensure responsible alcohol sales.

A Look Abroad: The Global E-commerce Boom

The global market paints a contrasting picture. 

According to IWSR Drinks Market Analysis, sales of alcohol through e-commerce channels in 16 major markets are expected to reach nearly USD 40 billion by 2027, with the US, Japan, and China leading the charge. India, with its massive population and burgeoning internet user base, has the potential to be a significant player in this space. 

Conclusion:

If implemented effectively, home delivery has the potential to further increase these revenue streams for state governments. Increased sales volume driven by convenience and wider selection could lead to a rise in VAT and excise collections. Additionally, proper regulation of online sales could potentially prevent tax evasion practices sometimes associated with traditional liquor stores.

In essence, home delivery of alcoholic beverages presents a win-win-win situation for e-commerce platforms, consumers, and state governments. However, it’s crucial to acknowledge the challenges and concerns that must be addressed for this reform to succeed.

*Disclaimer Note: The securities quoted, if any, are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. This article is for education purposes only and shall not be considered as recommendation or investment advice by Research & Ranking. We will not be liable for any losses that may occur. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. Registration granted by SEBI, membership of BASL, and certification from NISM in no way guarantee the performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.